Australia's house prices are through the roof. How did we get here?
We all know house prices keep going up.
I do not need to tell you about the Australian property market. News publications are full of articles about the seemingly never-ending increase in house prices. I do not need to tell you house prices in Australia rose almost 17 per cent in the 12 month period ending in June this year. Nor do I need to tell you record low interest rates and first homebuyers’ grants increase demand and therefore prices.
Home ownership in Australia has continued to decline. Census data from 2016 shows the proportion of private dwellings owner-occupied that year was 67 per cent, the lowest since records began in in 1954. The figures are starker for younger adults. Between 1971 and 2016 home ownership for 25- to 34-year-olds fell from 57 percent to 44.6 per cent.
Australia used to have one of the highest rates of homeownership in the world. Between 1947 and 1961, home ownership rose by more than 17 percentage points to almost 70 per cent.
By 1966 it reached 72.5 per cent.
The two bodies who have the most power to intervene in the property market, the federal government and the Reserve Bank of Australia, are not budging. If the government was hoping to shift the burden to the RBA, it backfired. In September Reserve Bank Governor Phillip Lowe made it clear lifting interest rates was not on its agenda.
Governments are unlikely to intervene because, to put it simply, the 5.4 million households owned by their occupiers do not want them to. Australia’s household wealth is strongly tied to house prices. As journalist Greg Jericho points out, no government wants to be tarred with slowing the growth of personal wealth. Associate Professor in Urban Planning at the University of Melbourne, David Nichols, says governments will do “bugger all” because “there’s too many people who are not going to accept their house being worth less”.
How did we get here?
The most lauded of all Liberal prime ministers, Sir Robert Menzies, in his famous Forgotten People speech of 1942, speaks of “homes material, homes human and homes spiritual”. Menzies positioned the home as a symbol of moral character, expressed though the virtues of “frugality and saving”.
This established the home at the ideological heart of post-war Australia. For Menzies, the home was also the bulwark against the evils of trade unionism and socialism. Economist Richard Dennis also points out Menzies knew people with 25-year mortgages would be more likely to go to work, pay their bills and vote conservative.
Capitalism underwent a transformation under the Hawke-Keating Labor government of the 1980s. This was guided by supply side economics, which has engineered a massive transfer of wealth upwards, creating a growing gap between rich and poor. According to the Australian Council of Social Services, today the average wealth of a household in the highest 20 per cent wealth group is over 90 times that of the lowest 20 per cent.
Principal Research Fellow at the Centre for Social Research and Methods at the Australian National University, Ben Phillips, says the large reduction in interest rates that began in the 1980s resulted in people "expecting to see low figures". He says the market became favourable for housing in the 1990s, and a reduction in capital gains tax and negative gearing meant people started to view housing as “a place where they could make money”.
The Howard government scrapped the indexation of capital gains and introduced a 50 per cent discount. It also boosted immigration and first home buyers grants which put further pressure on housing demand. Experts have slammed first home buyers’ grants as being ineffective at stabilising house prices. These first appeared in 1964 under the Menzies government at the request of the Young Liberal Movement, whose president at the time happened to be a young John Howard. The Howard government’s electorally motivated push to middle-class welfare also included family tax and private health rebates.
Phillips says it was during this time Australians started putting their money into property as an investment. He believes stock market crashes have potentially spooked some people out of investing in shares. “The average mum and dad investor understands bricks and mortar over shares," he says.
So here we are, where the median prices in Sydney and Melbourne, are $1,410,133 and $1,022,927 respectively, and the estimated value of residential real estate is more than $9 trillion.
Can anything be done?
Perhaps, but it is unlikely. Again, with 67 per cent of Australians owning their own home there is not a lot of pressure on governments to put a lid on prices. Phillips says “having five or six years where house prices are stable and wages grow” would be a prefarable scenario. He also says “reducing negative gearing and discounts on capital gains tax, and restricting the kinds of loans people can get” could help to dampen soaring prices.
Is it still naive to aspire to Menzies ideal that “one of the best instincts in us is that which induces us to have one little piece of earth with a house and a garden which is ours?” Looks like the best thing we can do is hope.
Image credits
Story:
Fast speed video Melboune Video: Tetrakissphericon, Pixabay
Black and white video: Life on Super 8, Pexels
Reserve Bank photo: Olga Kashubin , Shutterstock
Planted money photo: Suntezza, Shuttershock Sir Robert Menzies: R.L Stewart 1951 1950's Scene: Courtesy State Library of Victoria Postcard: MM_photos, Shuttershock Building house plans photo: Romolo Tavani, Shuttershock Ariel of Sydney: Photo by Mudassir Ali, Pexels
Video credits: pedestrians ariel Video: Timo Volz from Pexels
Ariel footage town by beach: Danilo Riba, Pexels
Music: 'Perception', Bensound.com
Houses roofs video Video: Kindel Media, Pexels
Video of suburbs from car: Sunshine Design, Pexels
Woman on holiday photo: Nappy, Pexels
Video library files: Tommyvideo, Pixabay
Vido of hands typing: Ujjal Khan, Pexels
Rental house video: Ivan Samkov, Pexels
Melbourne fast speed video: Tetrakis Sphericon, Pexels
Man with boxes video: RODANE, Pexels
Anthony Albanese Labor party photo: Facebook/Anthony Albanese
Apartments video: Dronestockclips, Pixabay
