The dark reality of being a woman in football

By Davina Bhakta

Football - A multi-billion pound industry which has become the most lucrative sport globally, yet unsurprisingly till this day is masked by rife sexism that is grabbing the headlines.

Being a woman in football is tiring. They are continuously told they have no place to watch nor speak on the “men’s game” as any form of their involvement is met with unwavering abuse and misogyny.

This year, sexism has reached new heights and intensified online for female journalists and broadcasters where more women than ever are publicly voicing their mistreatment.

Although talented women like Alex Scott and Laura Woods are rightfully afforded high-profile opportunities on sports desks, matchday panels and podcasts, the fight for acceptance and belonging still goes on.

This repetitive, predictable narrative is used against females with a prominent role in the industry; an outcry of “political correctness and tokenism” levelled at any opportunity, that is inescapable in the world of social media.

Accused for a lack of knowledge, competency and so called incorrect football opinions is expected - even in 2024.

These views have prevailed in society since the 1980s and 1990s and despite the seemingly positive progress in reaching equality, female broadcasters continue to face an uphill battle to prove their worth.

Manchester City presenter and No Tippy Tappy Football podcast host Natalie Pike said this argument is familiar territory for her.

After starting a career in modelling at age 21, Natalie was given the chance to showcase the new Citizens kit for the 2008/09 season which kickstarted her broadcasting career at the club.

Whilst working at a charity in her main job, she would spend the weekends working on gamedays in the City Square live broadcast shows at the Etihad Stadium, securing her first full-time role in 2011.

After more than ten years, Natalie was named the first woman to win Broadcaster of the Season at the 2023 Northwest Football Awards. 

Though a decade on after becoming a recognised name in the sports media, the 41-year-old said she has never felt more singled out and targeted.

This came after male ex-footballer Joey Barton’s Twitter tirade over a series of online sexist posts, vilifying women and pundits commenting on men’s football, as Natalie was merely one of his several attacks.

On his outburst towards her, she describes the constant fear of the unknown as a woman in this space and knew she was on the list to come for her one day.

“I was volunteering on my son’s school trip and my phone was going mad in my pocket. When my friend messaged me saying ‘ignore him’ my heart completely sank, I started panicking and shaking thinking what has he said and what have I done.”

With over two million followers, Barton quote tweeted a clip from Natalie’s podcast asking, “would love to know what this female contributes here from a footballing perspective?” following another remark “didn’t she used to be a page three model?”.

“The first insult I couldn’t comprehend, picking apart my own show when I’m simply letting the guest speak and the other is completely false - it’s ill-informed statements like this driven by an agenda that makes social media so toxic.

“There were about 1,000 replies to his tweet, many of men with those misogynistic attitudes but honestly I was surprised to see the positivity and backing I got on one hand which actually made my head so big,” Natalie said.

Presenting Manchester City 2021/22 Premier League trophy ceremony. Credit: Natalie Pike

Presenting Manchester City 2021/22 Premier League trophy ceremony. Credit: Natalie Pike

Starting the No Tippy Tappy Football podcast in November 2022 with ex England manager, Sam Allardyce has seen great success with its regular listeners.

Natalie recalls her discussion with former Premier League referee Mark Clattenburg where she questioned some of his controversial comments on female officials and said she "couldn’t wait to ask him his reasoning".

No Tippy Tappy podcast episode with Mark Clattenburg. Credit: Natalie Pike

No Tippy Tappy podcast episode with Mark Clattenburg. Credit: Natalie Pike

She added: “In many ways, this kind of unwarranted slander only motivates me further and has fuelled my fire to never miss the opportunity to front somebody up on things they’ve said, whether it’s right or wrong.”

She explains that trolling worsens around a big game and recently from the Five Live 606 fan phone in, where male fans had come out in their numbers to send nasty messages.

“I’ve learnt to be mentally strong and many times I’ve had to switch off my accounts to avoid consuming negativity and keep peace of mind.

“It’s frustrating and isn’t something we should be forced to do as social media presence is important in my job, but unfortunately it’s the only option.”

As a lifelong City fan, Natalie’s career is not one she ever imagined and while the everyday challenges unveil the ugly side of football, each day is still a pinch me moment. 

“My favourite memory was presenting our show pitch side at the Champions League final which got 6.5 million viewers that day and the treble winning parade calling Pep Guardiola and the players on stage was special.”

"I would get death threats and weekly letters sent in my inbox of desperately unpleasant abuse."

Jacqui Oatley MBE

Credit: Jacqui Oatley

Credit: Jacqui Oatley

Worryingly, Women in Football’s most recent survey reported that 82% of women have faced workplace discrimination in the form of sexism, sexual harassment and derogatory comments - up from 66% in 2020.

Jacqui hosting at the Football Writers' Association awards. Credit: Jacqui Oatley

Jacqui hosting at the Football Writers' Association awards. Credit: Jacqui Oatley

Jacqui was brought on to the FWA's National Commitee by pioneer female reporter, Vikki Orvice. Credit: Jacqui Oatley

Jacqui was brought on to the FWA's National Commitee by pioneer female reporter, Vikki Orvice. Credit: Jacqui Oatley

The differential treatment over a female appointment has sadly long existed.

With over 20 years of experience, Jacqui Oatley MBE made history in 2007 as the first female commentator on Match of the Day, earning her accolades from when she was attending press conferences for BBC London and working her way up covering non-league football.

When she turned 27 and suffered a horrible knee injury playing football, it was a life turning point to pursue her innate passion for sport commentary.

“Being a part of MOTD was a surreal week but also the toughest time of my career. The publicity was sour, it was not one I revelled in being in the limelight and on every newspaper’s back page.

“I was disheartened seeing all the crazy assumptions on my background like they knew me personally.

"The preconceived ideas that she must scream like a banshee and must quit with her whiny pitch angered me."
Jacqui Oatley, 49

“I respect commentary is subjective but it went a step too far, getting death threats and weekly letters sent in my inbox of desperately unpleasant abuse the police had to get involved with - all when I was six months pregnant presenting at the BBC,” Jacqui said.

She attributes the scrutiny to those who just can’t accept a female voice mixing up the arena as back then people were used to hearing the likes of John Motson, Alan Green and Barry Moore.

“There were no females for me to look up to so everything was self-taught, I would diligently spend ten hours a day for preparation ahead of a game and felt I’ve always had to go the extra mile compared to my male counterparts.”

Ultimately, for a woman it’s an unforgiving industry waiting to pounce on any slip up with inevitable criticism - as Jacqui’s friend found out when she accidentally said a goal was scored but had actually been ruled out for offside.

“I’ve been in that position when the crowd overpowers your thoughts, it’s a human mistake and ended up getting her sacked when I know two male reporters on BBC and Sky who made exactly the same error and nobody batted an eyelid.

Jacqui added: “We are judged by different standards and I’ve had to grow extra layers of skin to survive in this cut-throat environment where there’s nowhere to hide as a woman.”

Jacqui Oatley on the publicity as Match of the Day's first female commentator.

Jacqui Oatley on the publicity as Match of the Day's first female commentator.

While now there are trailblazers and mentors like Jacqui Oatley to admire in the broadcasting world, print journalism paves the way for the starkest gender disparity as only 3% of Football Writers’ Association (FWA) members are women.

Nancy Froston, an EFL Correspondent for The Athletic believes the fact the number is so low represents the barriers a woman writer faces in sport.

Player interview with Notts County winger, Jodi Jones. Credit: Nancy Froston

Player interview with Notts County winger, Jodi Jones. Credit: Nancy Froston

“It’s a growing concern, even at my job there’s been an improvement but still just one female editor is in a senior position so there’s a long way to go.

“I think knowledge is assumed in men who write about football whereas I’ve had to prove myself over six years that I understand tactics and management, despite my qualifications and covering over hundreds of matches.”

Nancy is also struggling with all the negative spotlight around women at the moment and said: “Frankly, the last six to nine months hasn’t been a very nice place to work in and has bogged me down quite a lot.”

Serving on the national committee of the FWA, Jacqui Oatley is keen on increasing the numbers by advocating for more gifted females in print courses, writing competitions and securing opportunities at national newspapers.

Garibaldi Girls will be Nottingham Forest's first ever official female supporter group

These shocking statistics are just a snapshot to the hateful abuse a female fan suffers on a daily basis.

Ellie Molloson, 20, is an avid season ticket holder at Nottingham Forest and founder of the club’s first female supporters group, Garibaldi Girls - launching later this year.

“In the last year I’ve faced more sexism than I ever have before,” Ellie said.

“It’s worst in the form of hyper-sexualisation at away games where there’s been inappropriate touching and gestures. Yet, when I’ve gone through the formal reporting system I’m told it’s victim blaming and ignored.”

However, Ellie is determined to safely improve the matchday experience for women and not be put off watching their team.

“The group will be a nice community for women with meetups, pre-match events and making new friends so every female supporter feels valued and respected at The City Ground.”

Ellie was a speaker at the club’s landmark racism and gender inequality conference on February, 1 with Harvard University amongst footballing legends in Lilian Thuram and Thierry Henry.

“I couldn’t have dreamed of being on the panel doing such a vital speech on the history of sexism, it’s given me an incredible platform and massively helped the progression of Garibaldi Girls."

Ellie Molloson

Ellie speaking at the Nottingham Forest gender inequality conference. Credit: Ellie Molloson

Ellie speaking at the Nottingham Forest gender inequality conference. Credit: Ellie Molloson

Dr Ali Bowes, a senior lecturer with specific interest in gender and sport, shares the view that ingrained sexist beliefs are stemmed from the embedded male privilege and hegemonic masculine culture of football.

“From historical research, we know the football industry is male-dominated and vitriolic abuse has deteriorated online into echo chambers of hate speech.

“It’s challenging to filter through every troll account but firmer social media regulation needs to be implemented. The current system on verified users is only inciting aggression and giving misogyny greater reach.

“Importantly, broadcast companies hold power and global marketability to influence positive change with their media coverage of a systemic issue like sexism.

She added: “They can be braver with what gender equality looks like in their organisations by valuing female employees and offering them commanding positions which sets the example for unified action in the football ecosystem.”

A study published in the 2020 Sociology of Sport Journal analysed the opinions of football fans on the inclusion of women as fans, broadcasters, journalists, board members and referees.

Between 2015 and 2016 the authors surveyed 2,347 fans anonymously.

John Williams, sociologist and co-author at the University of Leicester believes that the white male fandom feels threatened by emerging women and ethnic minorities in the sport.

“Findings showed a group of male fans who wanted to appear to be more supportive because of the general shift of popularity but still remained opposed in their views, which was new.

“In this digital age, male resistance has exacerbated and will stay pronounced but the increased visibility of women in football is optimistic.”

Making significant strides to combat gender inequality the award-winning, anti-sexism movement #HerGameToo are pioneering female inclusivity while encouraging women and girls to play sports and share their opinions.

Credit: Her Game Too

Credit: Her Game Too

#HerGameToo Launch Video

Credit: Caz May

Credit: Caz May

Being female-founded lends the group authenticity as together each woman’s harrowing story is powerful and at the face of its mission.

This harsh, visual approach struck success in opening the eyes of football clubs and sports media organisations.

Celebrating its three year anniversary this month, the campaign was an instant hit following a viral launch video holding cards of sexist comments, which amassed over two million views within 48 hours.

With over 100 female ambassadors and 75 clubs in the UK and France on board already pledging their support, founder Caz May thinks the upcoming year will be their best yet as they aim to reach the goal of all 92 clubs from the Premier League down to League Two.

“There wasn’t a day that went by where I didn’t receive the classic lines like get back in the kitchen from misogynists.

“I knew something had to be done when I was in a pub and a man grabbed me closer whispering take your top off, I felt objectified and disgusted.

The Gasheads fan added: “What really hurt me was after Bristol Rovers became the second professional club signed up with #HGT, some of my own supporters wrote We Hate Caz on the wall in the men’s toilets which was sent to me online.

“I wasn’t sleeping, my mental health got quite bad to the point where I couldn’t go into work because I was scared and really anxious.”

Caz said these difficult experiences have spurred her aspirations with #HerGameToo and will not allow herself to rest until she sees a real meaningful change.

“We want to continue to see an increase in female season ticket holders at the main stadiums, more women’s teams affiliated with the main club’s and develop our education pieces with workshops to show from a young age that girls can play, comment and work in football.

“We know that given the exposure and facilities women’s football can flourish, it’s amazing to see our work increase visitor attendances like when Ipswich Town Ladies normally get 500, they played at Portman Road and it went up to 10,000 spectators.

“As women with different backgrounds keep sharing their stories, the further this will go along with the more influential males that stand by us.”

The sexism battle started as a passion project and till this day all ambassadors are unpaid and involved due to their sheer dedication of fighting the cause.

Caz believes with future financial backing the message will only get stronger.

“We’ve got many exciting things planned, attracting interest from EA Sports and these big organisations can offer their expertise and help us grow to international leagues."

Last year, at the Football Content Awards #HerGameToo won the Equality, Diversity and Inclusion award and the Best in Women’s Football award - the latter for the second year running.

#HerGameToo girls football workshop. Credit: Caz May

#HerGameToo girls football workshop. Credit: Caz May

#HerGameToo founders Caz May (right) and Amy Clement (left) winners at the 2023 Football Content Awards. Credit: Caz May

#HerGameToo founders Caz May (right) and Amy Clement (left) winners at the 2023 Football Content Awards. Credit: Caz May

Initiatives such as Garibaldi Girls and #HerGameToo are a step forward in showing the football industry the everyday realities of what it’s like to be a woman in sport.

Yet the glaring statistics which have unfolded reveal that achieving parity for women working in and following football is still only scratching the surface.

As the Men’s Euros looms, it seems unavoidable for sexist abuse to escalate again irrespective of the efforts from these campaigns.

Although they cannot preclude sexism, more awareness and coverage of the issue on the world stage will help drive serious progress.

This is a Shorthand story for reviewPublished stories don't show this section.

GIVE FEEDBACK TO THE STORY OWNER

This feature is not available in landscape. Please rotate your device.

GIVE FEEDBACK TO THE STORY OWNER

More than 4 characters is required
Name must contain only letters, hyphens, apostrophes, full-stops and spaces
Wait, that does not look like a valid email address!
Your feedback was sent to the story owner.
There is been an issue with submitting your feedback.

TEST ON ANOTHER DEVICE

This feature is not available in landscape. Please rotate your device.

TEST ON ANOTHER DEVICE