THE RISING TIDE ON CLIMATE CHANGE, RACISM AND HUMAN RIGHTS
Is Australia blind to the effects climate change is having on Pacific and Torres Strait Islander peoples and their human rights?
Living in fear is something Claire Anterea, 42, knows a great deal about.
Her first memory of feeling the effects of climate change was in 2005 when storms and strong winds tore down homes, trees and ate away at roads.
“The sea came during the night, people slept and all this wind and waves just started breaking their houses. A lot of trees and roads were eaten away. It was so sad to see and it made us so scared to see all these things that we had never seen before and now it is constant, it has become more frequent than before,” Mrs Anterea said.
She and her family live on the island of South Tarawa in Kiribati, where rain hasn’t fallen in nearly a year and ocean levels are rising everyday.
Mrs Anterea’s biggest worry is that Kiribati won’t exist for her children and grandchildren to live and call home.
“Scientists have said that our islands will be submerged, will be under the sea and that our islands will no longer be on the map. Where will we go then? We don’t have a place to go if that happens. I still can’t get my head around it because if the sea keeps rising our islands will disappear…So that’s the fear I carry with me,” she said. “We really love our country, it is the most peaceful place that I’ve known and so I don’t want that to happen.”
Claire Anterea, 42, member of KiriCan, giving speech. Photo: Supplied by Claire Anterea.
Claire Anterea, 42, member of KiriCan, giving speech. Photo: Supplied by Claire Anterea.
South Tarawa shoreline lined with rocks. Photo: Supplied by Claire Anterea.
South Tarawa shoreline lined with rocks. Photo: Supplied by Claire Anterea.
Claire and her daughter seen smiling and laughing on the beach. Photo: Supplied by Claire Anterea.
Claire and her daughter seen smiling and laughing on the beach. Photo: Supplied by Claire Anterea.
Carbon emissions in Australia have dropped to a two decade low thanks to Coronavirus halting travel by air and limiting the amount of cars on the road.
But not everyone sees this as a positive.
Pacific and Torres Strait islanders bear the brunt of climate change caused by high emitting countries like Australia.
And people like Claire Anterea can’t understand why a resourceful country such as Australia won’t move to using renewables to lower carbon emissions into the future.
Last year, eight Torres Strait islanders took a complaint to the United Nations Human Rights Committee, calling out Australia’s inaction on climate change in the region.
The Australian Federal Government has since responded to the claim, asking the UN to disregard the complaint as climate change is not yet affecting people of the Torres Strait and their human rights.
An average Australian produces 18 times the amount of emissions than the average person living in Indonesia, meaning people living in crowded cities and low lying archipelagos will be more impacted by climate change while contributing very little to the problem.
“Climate change is all around the world but in a different form to what we experience. It is really sad and annoying.”
I think that climate change causes more of a divide between economic status rather than race. However, in Australia the separation between economic statuses unfortunately separates white Australia from indigenous Australians as indigenous people tend to be of a lower economic status, meaning they have less access to technology and education in order to address the issue of climate change. I do not think that it is a violation of human rights as almost all people are contributing to the pollution of our atmosphere whether it be through the clothes we wear, cars we drive, heating, foods we eat, toys we buy and give etc. If it is a human rights issue then we are all responsible for violating our own human rights. I do think that society has turned a blind eye to climate change and deemed it as something that is socially acceptable and something not worth drawing a lot of attention to as the industries we have that contribute to climate change generate billions of dollars for the Australian economy. The economic benefit outweighs the environmental benefit as the damage we do today won’t be seen by us tomorrow.
I hadn’t really thought about how climate change is linked to racism before, although I had thought about how climate change will have a greater impact on those more vulnerable in the world. I believe climate change will challenge our human rights. It will definitely decrease our choices in life to some extent. It may be as small as no longer being able to continue a certain sport or hobby, but a fear I have is it may be as significant as limiting people’s choice on whether they can have children or not.
“I’ve heard from politicians in Australia and they think we are just making up stories about this and people are different and I don’t know how to change those people but in a way we know that we are experiencing the threats from this side of the world more badly than you guys because we have small islands, we have skinny islands to live on.”
Personally, I’ve always looked at climate change as not only a political and economic issue but definitely a human rights issue because it does affect the wellbeing of people and it will affect so many people and does. What’s going to be available to us if climate change does get to a point where we can’t turn it back around and where do we go from there? If we continue to do the things that we’re doing that aren’t good for the planet, how long is the world actually going to sustain us? In regards to climate change linking to racism, I haven’t actually thought to link it but it’s definitely something I’d love more information on.
Wendy Flannery, Friends of the Earth Brisbane’s Pacific and Torres Strait Island Climate Justice coordinator, says people in the mainstream in Australia don’t take stories from the Pacific seriously when it comes to climate change.
“It’s almost as if they have this tawdry image of the Pacific as a paradise. They still use the language of ‘spoiling paradise’, as if people who live in the Pacific live in a paradise anyway and to get through those stereotypes is quite difficult,” she said.
“[Our main goal is] to try and get the Australian population on board with climate justice, recognising that whatever happens in Australia is having a huge impact on the Pacific.”
Mrs Anterea knows the feeling of not being heard by Australian politicians, having travelled to Canberra two years ago to meet with the government.
She said politicians were very confident that people from the Pacific, herself included, were just making up stories about the problem and the issues they were facing.
“I think Australia says proudly that they give a lot of money to the Pacific but they give us money to build a seawall but the water keeps rising. How long are they going to give us money to build these and it’s not working? Building a seawall is not the answer to the problem because if you build a seawall in Kiribati, it may be, ‘Can I afford a seawall? How about the next door neighbour? They will get the effects of my seawall, they will get even more force on their land and they will lose their land but I will keep building up my seawall.’ For me, it is not about money because I know Australia says, ‘I know but I give you money, I always give you money’ but I think money can’t buy our survival.”
Both Mrs Flannery and Cam Walker, Climate Justice coordinator for Friends of the Earth Melbourne, say framing Australia’s inaction as racist has merit but it is not the best way to look at it.
“The ‘small island states’, even that language, tends to separate the big and the small and the big and the small of course does have touches of racism in it because Australia is a predominately colonised country.”
“So of course [Australia is] potentially racist because we’re virtually exporting our emissions to countries that are not causing any of them,” Mrs Flannery said.
Mr Walker says the Australian government has not done enough to challenge climate deniers and fossil fuel companies.
“You have to argue at the very least, Australian’s are blind to this concept of carbon debt, that is we owe a debt to the rest of the planet for our very high individual consumption of resources and production of greenhouse gases,” he said.
Mrs Flannery prefers the term nvironmental crimes” to address Australia’s blindness to climate change. “The fact that we’re not prepared to make a significant contribution to lowering greenhouse gases when we know that we’ve got one of the highest per capita emissions on the planet means that we’re not serious about our neighbours.”
Heavy winds and dry landscape of Kiribati during drought. Photo: Supplied by Claire Anterea.
Heavy winds and dry landscape of Kiribati during drought. Photo: Supplied by Claire Anterea.
Claire Anterea visiting Sydney in 2008. Photo: Supplied by Claire Anterea.
Claire Anterea visiting Sydney in 2008. Photo: Supplied by Claire Anterea.
Kiribati shoreline with seawall. Photo: Supplied by Claire Anterea.
Kiribati shoreline with seawall. Photo: Supplied by Claire Anterea.
Coconut trees left bare after a storm. Photo: Supplied by Wendy Flannery. Music: Bensound.
Coconut trees left bare after a storm. Photo: Supplied by Wendy Flannery. Music: Bensound.
Living in this reality is something Mrs Anterea has come to understand with her 10 years of work with the Kiribati Climate Action Network.
Every day she experiences the effects of climate change.
King tides and natural disasters are more frequent; warmer temperatures and longer lasting drought; and rising sea levels and ocean acidification are taking away fundamental rights that the UN sees as universal.
Research conducted by the Australian Bureau of Meteorology, CSIRO and the Kiribati Meteorology Service, shows sea levels have risen by one to four millimetres each year since 1993 in the Kiribati region.
Rising sea levels increase the possibility of natural disasters like storm surges, king tides and flooding, caused by weather patterns of El Nino and La Nina.
The right to clean water is something Mrs Anterea’s family struggles with every day. Their 10,000 litre water tank has run dry.
“The only source of water we have now is to drink from the well water, which is not so good because the place is so over populated but it’s the only water we can drink and we have to boil it and we’re not sure if we kill every creature in the water,” she said.
As tides topple over seawalls, freshwater wells are contaminated with salty water and oceans continue to acidify, absorbing 25 to 33 per cent of carbon dioxide from the air, harming reefs and marine life.
Claire and fellow colleagues at the United Nations Climate Conference in Bali, Indonesia, 2007. Photo: Supplied by Claire Anterea.
Claire and fellow colleagues at the United Nations Climate Conference in Bali, Indonesia, 2007. Photo: Supplied by Claire Anterea.
Claire, with her husband and daughter on the beach. Ship arrives with rain water tanks for the South Tarawa Community. Photo: Supplied by Claire Anterea.
Claire, with her husband and daughter on the beach. Ship arrives with rain water tanks for the South Tarawa Community. Photo: Supplied by Claire Anterea.
Not only do island countries rely on reefs and sea life for food security and livelihoods but reefs protect shorelines from 97 per cent of wave energy that could otherwise cause further erosion.
Families like Mrs Anterea’s also depend on the ocean as part of their culture.
This video has been put together with photos supplied by Claire Anterea, Wendy Flannery and Mikayla van Loon. Voice: Claire Anterea.
This video has been put together with photos supplied by Claire Anterea, Wendy Flannery and Mikayla van Loon. Voice: Claire Anterea.
Mrs Anterea says that migrating somewhere else is not a solution to the problem but a last resort. She does not want to be a burden to another country like Australia or New Zealand.
The current Kiribati government does not want to relocate as the previous government did; instead they want to stay and fight.
“We really don’t want to move, we really want to stay here,” Mrs Anterea said.
Desalination plants are part of the Kiribati government’s plans to allow people to continue living in Tarawea but for the survival of people on all 32 islands, millions of dollars would need to be invested, which Kiribati doesn’t have the capacity to do.
“But if [governments] do their part in their own country, I think we will start adding our own resources back, we will have rain more frequently like we used to,” Mrs Anterea said.
“It just makes me angry because all presidents in the world know that if they cut their emissions, the world will survive and you don’t have to teach them, they know everything about it and that Kiribati is impacted by this. They know everything about our situation but it’s just a matter of sacrificing, of letting go of their own comfort.”
Victorian Energy, Environment and Climate Change Minister Lily D'Ambrosio was contacted but was unavailable for comment.
Music: Bensound.
Music: Bensound.
