Endless times of torment and battles
that seem to be coming to a crucial point.
How did the LGBT+ community
as it is known today form?
What is happening in this regard?
Let's try to look at how the world
approaches this theme.
No longer
invisibile
Karl-Heinrich Ulrichs, the father of the LGBT+ movement who spoke openly about gay rights
He was the first to break down the halo of mystery and prejudice that covered a disheartened and misunderstood community. It was only 1867, but the world enriched with cultural and social history continued to evolve, and with it the history of the LGBT+ community.
The nineteenth-century conscience, the child of post-Enlightenment and early Romanticism, began to resent the kind of severity society was used to witness.
In the course of the century, in fact, those guilty of sodomy, caught in the act, were no longer condemned to the stake, but relegated to the provinces or interned in some hospital.
If before, same-sex sexual relations were lumped together with magic, witchcraft and heresy, now they began to be considered a disease or a less serious fault than before.
And shortly after?
Psychopathia Sexualis, Richard Freiherr von Krafft-Ebing
Psychopathia Sexualis, Richard Freiherr von Krafft-Ebing
For the first time, in the late 1800s, the term "bisexual" was used in a psychiatry textbook, "Psychopathia Sexualis", expanding studies on the human sexual spectrum and analysing its different nuances.
If previously they risked being condemned to the stake, now they risk, alongside moral condemnation, becoming phenomena to be studied.
The consequence was that these people first used to hide their orientation for fear of being burnt alive, then they hided so as not to become the object of scandal or medical attention.
One night, one change
From 28 June to 3 July 1969, a series of violent clashes between LGBT+ groups and the police in New York City characterised five nights, known as "The Stonewall Riot".
In unison, at the Stonewall Inn. hundreds of people shouted in honour of their rights, giving rise to the 1970 Prides in New York, Los Angeles and San Francisco.
For the first time, the LGBT+ community demanded equality, no longer exclusion. It demanded judgmental protections, not more violence.
For the first time, a new narrative was being created.
The historic clashes of June '69 gave birth to the dignity of a community, no longer invisible and disrespected.
They urged and still urge countries around the world to recognise the rights of all people regardless of their sexual orientation and gender identity.
No longer silent, not even in politics
David McReynolds in one of his first public debates
David McReynolds in one of his first public debates
The citizens of America began to demand full representation and political honesty, especially after the events of the past decade.
And so a decade later new political representatives emerged, as David McReynolds, first openly homosexual candidate in the American presidential elections.
In the United States, the first footprints of inclusion were marked towards the LGBT+ environment and the first debates on this issue, one of the most prejudiced along with racism.
Various athletes take part in the opening ceremonies at the 1990 Gay Games in Vancouver
Various athletes take part in the opening ceremonies at the 1990 Gay Games in Vancouver
On the 17 May on 1990, something historical happened: the World Health Organisation (WHO) has removed homosexuality from the list of mental illnesses.
The main factors that contributed to the social stigma attached to to homosexuality and what they considered "hate crimes and deviant acts" were reviewed and discussed.
The removal of homosexuality from the list of mental illnesses was an historic moment, so much so that it led in 2004 to choose 17 May as the date for the establishment of the International Day Against
homophobia (International Day Against Homophobia, Biphobia and Transphobia).
Yet, 30 years after the WHO resolution, in many countries practices such as reparative therapies still exist and only recently some governments are working to ban them.
History always looks to the past to explain the present.
What is the situation of LGBT+ citizens in Europe?
LGBT+ individuals continue to face prejudice around the world today, but protecting their rights has long been a priority for the EU.
Indeed, the European Commission has been actively promoting equality and fairness for the past 25 years, with the goal of raising awareness of people's rights in this community and demonstrating to the rest of the world that no matter who you love or who you are, everyone should have the same rights.
Fundamental legal texts such as the Treaty of Amsterdam (1997), the Charter of Fundamental Rights (2000), and anti-discrimination directives all provide protection for LGBT+ individuals.
Of course, the situation differs from nation to country within the EU.
The European Parliament declaring the European Union an "LGBT+ Freedom Zone"
The European Parliament declaring the European Union an "LGBT+ Freedom Zone"
In addition, since 2003 it has been illegal in the EU to discriminate against people in the workplace on the basis of their sexual orientation. Legislation requires all EU countries to legally protect citizens against discrimination in connection with applying for a job, professional promotion or training activities, or in relation to working conditions, pay and dismissal.
Nevertheless, in 2013 the European Commission presented the results of an investigation that showed that, across Europe, thousands of people suffer discrimination, harassment, hate speech and violence, to the detriment of the full enjoyment of their fundamental rights.
Some EU countries are even reversing their positions on LGBT+ rights. Even in countries that have achieved significant progress in this area, incitement to hatred and incidents of homophobic and transphobic violence are all too common.
To address this dilemma, the EU is presently developing new policies. Recent data, updated to 2022 and provided by ILGA-Europe (International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association), present a transparent picture of the European situation with regard to the non-respected human rights of LGBT+ people.
Rainbow Map 2022, ILGA-Europe
Rainbow Map 2022, ILGA-Europe
What criteria does ILGA-Europe use to determine these rankings?
The rankings are based on how each country's laws and policies affect the lives of LGBT+ persons. The rating keeps track of a country's legal norms so that it can be compared to its European neighbors.
Country ranking, ILGA-Europe
Country ranking, ILGA-Europe
The color allocated to each country indicates where it ranks on a scale of 0 percent (severe abuses of human rights, discrimination) to 100 percent (no violations of human rights, no discrimination, respect of human rights, full equality).
The history of two symbiotic countries such as Portugal and Brazil can be a useful source for a present-day perspective.
Near and far at the same time.
How different are their social situations nowadays?
What if we focus on their historical and modern relationship and on LGBT+ people's quality of life?
It is possible to see Portugal and Brazil as two increasingly distinct worlds, even though their past has been intertwined for centuries:
a historical narrative that presents events that form the roots of a country, such as colonialism, domination and independence.
In Brazil, contacts with the ancient motherland are sporadic and very rare.
Brazilians do not come into contact with Portuguese culture and are not influenced by it in any way.
And the same happens on the other side: the Portuguese also avoid being influenced by their overseas cousins.
Geographical distance will cause these two countries to live less and less symbiotically and lead to cultural distance.
It is now clear that they do not follow the linguistic and socio-cultural evolutions of each other and, step by step, they understand each other less and less.
LGBT+ rights in Brazil,
the two sides of a coin
Brazil is considered a particularly advanced nation in protecting and giving visibility to the LGBT+ community.
Contributing to this image is having recognised the legality of homosexuality since 1823 and being the scene of the largest Pride parade in the world.
The country has also distinguished itself internationally for making numerous contributions to the elimination of discrimination.
In 2004, Brazil submitted the Brazilian Resolution, the first draft resolution on the issue, to the United Nations.
As an example of the commitment to countering homophobic hatred, in 2008 President Lula da Silva inaugurated the country's first "National Conference of Gays, Lesbians, Bisexuals, Transvestites and Transsexuals", a direct confrontation between the institutions and organisations of the LGBT+ community to implement public policies and actions to improve the living conditions and rights of its members.
On the other hand, the situation does not seem to be the one guaranteed by the political class.
This is the judgement of MΓ΄nica BenΓcio, widow of activist and Rio de Janeiro city councillor Marielle Franco, who was murdered in 2018 for her efforts to counter police abuse.
The country's violence is immediately apparent from the statistics: according to activists, between 1980 and 2006, some 2680 homosexuals were murdered for reasons of discrimination, an average of 103 murders per year.
A protest against homophobia in Brazil
A protest against homophobia in Brazil
Recently, the figures have worsened: in 2019, the AssociaΓ§Γ£o Nacional de Travestis e Transexuais (ANTRA) recorded 175 murders motivated by homosexuality/transphobia, with the perpetrators being convicted in only 10% of the cases.
Brazil is therefore the nation with the highest number of victims of sexual orientation discrimination in the world, and it is not uncommon for Brazilian citizens to move to Portugal as a solution.
The data indicate, therefore, a serious marginalisation of the trans community in particular, with very high drop-out rates (82%) and exclusion from the labour market (90%).
Under these conditions, many members of this group end up involved in prostitution, thus exposing themselves to involvement in street crime and drug dealing.
This explains why the life expectancy of a trans person in Brazil is set at only thirty-five years.
And in Portugal?
In 2003, the first laws against discrimination based on sexual orientation in employment came into force, particularly in the areas of: access to work and employment, protection against discrimination in the workplace and against sexual harassment.
Since 2004, the constitution has prohibited any form of discrimination based on sexual orientation, making Portugal one of the few countries, in the world, only then, to sanction the prohibition of discrimination based on sexual orientation in its constitution.
In 2007, with the entry into force of the new penal code, Portugal expanded its anti-discrimination legislation.
In 2010, Portugal legalised egalitarian marriage, while in 2016 it also gave the green light to adoptions for same-sex couples and gestation for others.
Although laws are clear and are used to change the socio-culture of a country, the daily situation is controversial and it is not difficult to read about hate news.
Yesterday in Portugal people were trying to defend and victimize a 25 yo PEDOPHILE for dating a 15 yo, today people are trying to find ways to defend homophobia and make it an opinion. This people are insane, I regret bringing an EU Masters title to this country
β Manittas (@Manittas_) November 22, 2021
Students punished by school for protesting against homophobia. I thought we were over this shit Portugal. Foda-se
β ππππΌππ (@impaKt1K) May 25, 2017
A cena do Goucha e o Ramos Γ© q foram educados num Portugal em q a ΓΊnica forma d ser aceite como gay era assimilando a cultura hetero. Podiam ser gays se n fossem afeminados ou muito espampanantes. Portanto agora a homophobia estΓ‘ tΓ£o internalizada que ver outros homens gays 1/2
β r i c ξ¨ π³οΈβπ (@ricjpl) December 20, 2021
one time out in Portugal and makes me wanna go right back to london.... the homophobia/transphobia in this country is- I canβt do it
β noa (@jesuisfag) August 18, 2019
tw / abortion, death , xenophobia , racism , homophobia , sexual abuse
β nadyβ· (@jeonvias) January 16, 2021
WHAT'S HAPPENING IN PORTUGAL π΅πΉ
Someone made edits out of my thread and it's easier to spread so please read this and spread awareness, this is very serious and it's a threat to the country as we know it. https://t.co/rA5NWVhsdO pic.twitter.com/OirtK6939B
Why is every LGBTQIA person I meet, from Portugal who live in the UK, incredibly transphobic and with internalised homophobia?
β Rambi/Filipa (@rambinha) May 12, 2022
so, a gay couple got beat up by a family of 5 here in portugal just bc they were kissing goodbye,,, cool portugal keep it up with your homophobia, you're doing great
β soph πππ (@sofiav_333) July 16, 2018