Google Performance Max and Meta Advantage+: how good are Big Tech’s AI ad tools? 

PHD UK on what automated campaigns deliver, where they fall short, and what agencies still bring. 

An animated hand reaching out from behind a string of wires against a blue background. The hand is animated, with the strings of the wires reaching out in all directions.

Google Performance Max and Meta Advantage+: how good are Big Tech’s AI ad tools? 

PHD UK on what automated campaigns deliver, where they fall short, and what agencies still bring. 

An animated hand reaching out from behind a string of wires against a blue background. The hand is animated, with the strings of the wires reaching out in all directions.

By Conor Nichols, Special Reporter

Mark Zuckerberg has spoken of a future where a business simply tells Meta its objective and lets the AI handle the rest, from creative to targeting. Meta has since stressed that agencies still have an important role to play. 

Part of that future is already here. Google’s Performance Max and Meta’s Advantage+ ask advertisers for a goal, a budget, creative assets and conversion data. The platforms’ AI then decides who sees the ads, where they appear, which creative runs and how much to bid. Tasks that media teams once managed by hand can now be largely automated. 

So how good are these tools? We asked PHD UK’s Sophie Strong (Managing Partner, Addressable and Media Capability), Shiblu Ahmed (Head of Social) and Daniele Pramaggiore (Head of PPC) what the tools actually do, where they fall short, how to check the platforms’ numbers, and where agencies add value. 

What do Performance Max and Meta’s Advantage+ actually do? What does an advertiser hand over to the platform, and what do they still control?  

Sophie Strong

Sophie Strong
Managing Partner Addressable and Media Capability
PHD UK

Shiblu Ahmed

Shiblu Ahmed
Head of Social
PHD UK

Daniele Pramaggiore

Daniele Pramaggiore
Head of PPC
PHD UK

We are at an important moment for digital advertising because the way consumers interact with brands has fundamentally changed. The linear conversion journey is no more. Search behaviour is increasingly fragmented and unpredictable, while consumer expectations for personalisation continue to rise. A BCG study found that 80% of consumers are comfortable with personalised experiences and expect brands to deliver them. (Source: What Consumers Want from Personalization | BCG)  

Performance Max and Advantage+ are AI-led solutions designed for this new reality. Rather than advertisers manually managing bids, audiences, placements and keywords, they provide the platforms with key inputs such as business objectives, audience signals, creative assets, conversion data and budgets. The algorithms then determine who to target, where ads are served and what messages are shown.  

Google’s AI Max is accelerating this shift further by moving beyond advertiser-defined keywords and increasingly interpreting intent to identify new opportunities. The advertiser’s role is becoming less about directing every decision and more about providing the right objectives, signals and guardrails. 

Advertisers still retain control over the things that matter most: 

  • Business objectives and consultation  
  • Budgets  
  • Creative strategy  
  • Measurement frameworks  
  • Data and conversion signals  

Creative is particularly important in these environments. It is no longer just the message; it is one of the primary signals used by algorithms to determine who sees an ad and how effectively it performs.

At Omnicom Media and PHD UK we are increasingly helping clients shape creative strategies, reporting frameworks and governance processes to ensure these systems are learning from the strongest possible inputs while maintaining appropriate controls around how content is used.   

However, as these solutions evolve, advertisers also need to be increasingly conscious of what they are actually handing over to the platforms. Recent discussion around Meta's updated Commercial Terms has highlighted concerns around how platform AI systems may access, analyse and use advertiser-provided content, URLs and creative assets to improve AI-powered products and services. While these terms were introduced after many of these products launched, they reflect a broader shift in the industry:

Advertisers are no longer simply outsourcing media buying decisions, they are increasingly participating in AI ecosystems that learn from the content, signals and assets provided to them.

For publishers, content creators and brands with valuable intellectual property, understanding these commercial arrangements, governance requirements and AI training implications is becoming just as important as understanding the technology itself.  

In short, success is becoming less about managing campaigns and more about managing the quality of the data, creative and measurement that power them. In an AI-driven world, competitive advantage comes not just from giving platforms the right signals, but from ensuring the right governance and guardrails sit around them as well.  

 

How widely are you using them across your clients, and has that changed over the past year or two?  

Over the last two years, we have seen a significant shift in adoption.   

What began as a test-and-learn activity has become a core part of many clients’ always-on strategies. Initial hesitation around automation has largely disappeared as advertisers realised that traditional campaign structures can sometimes work against, rather than with, the algorithms. At PHD UK, we have seen improvements of up to 18% in ROAS-driven social campaigns alongside average CPM improvements of 7%.  

The biggest change has been where effort is invested. Teams are now spending less time building campaigns and managing bids, and more time focusing on strategic activity:  

  • First-party data and audience signals  
  • Measurement and incrementality  
  • MarTech infrastructure 
  • Creative strategy and testing  

Success is no longer purely about media buying expertise. Data strategy, measurement, MarTech and creative teams all play a much larger role in driving performance.  

Importantly, the opportunity extends beyond direct response. The brands seeing the strongest results are taking a full-funnel approach. Creator-led content on YouTube builds awareness, Demand Gen drives consideration and Performance Max converts demand into action. Together, these connected signals help AI better understand consumers, identify intent and make smarter optimisation decisions.  

Increasingly, the competitive advantage increasingly comes not from campaign execution itself, but from the quality of the data, measurement and creative inputs powering the algorithms.  

 

Where do these tools genuinely shine? Are there particular clients, categories or objectives where they consistently outperform a more hands-on approach?  

These tools tend to perform best for advertisers that have invested in the right foundations.  

The strongest results typically come from brands with high-quality first-party data, robust measurement frameworks and sufficient conversion volume for algorithms to learn effectively. Solutions such as CAPI, enhanced conversion tracking and omnichannel sales data provide richer signals for platforms to optimise against.  

Creative is another major differentiator. As platforms take on more optimisation decisions, the quality and breadth of creative assets become increasingly important. Advertisers that continually test and refresh creative tend to outperform those relying on a limited asset library.  

We have seen particularly strong results across retail, travel, technology and automotive categories, where there is sufficient data and conversion volume to fuel learning.

For one retail client, campaigns using the full Advantage+ suite delivered a 17% improvement in CVR and a 9% improvement in CPM compared with manually controlled campaigns. For a travel client, Advantage+ Sales reduced CPA by 70% while increasing ROI by 127%.  

Performance Max has similarly evolved from a testing initiative into a core part of our always-on Search strategy. Across our clients at PHD UK, we have seen it deliver approximately 27% lower CPA and 45% lower CPC when supported by strong conversion signals and quality data.  

More broadly, these solutions outperform a more hands-on approach when the objective is driving performance at scale. Their ability to process thousands of signals in real time and adapt to changing consumer behaviour is difficult to replicate manually.  

That said, the strongest results still come from combining platform automation with human expertise, ensuring performance translates into genuine business growth.  

Where do they fall short? Are there any examples where results looked strong in-platform but told a different story once you dug deeper?  

The biggest challenge is that these tools are only as good as the signals and objectives they are given.  

If advertisers are not clear on how a platform KPI connects to a business outcome, they risk training algorithms to optimise towards the wrong objective. We have seen examples where platform-reported performance appeared very strong, but the impact was far less pronounced when measured against broader business metrics such as incremental sales, profit or customer value.  

In these situations, the platform is often doing exactly what it was asked to do. The issue is that the KPI itself is not the right measure of success.  

A similar challenge exists within Google’s automated solutions. The easiest conversion is not always the most valuable or incremental one. Performance can appear very strong if activity is disproportionately capturing users who are already familiar with the brand or highly likely to convert.  

Meta’s automated placements can present similar challenges. While some lower-attention environments may deliver attractive in-platform metrics, they do not always translate into meaningful business outcomes.

This is why it is important to look beyond headline CPA or ROAS metrics and understand: 

  • Where demand is coming from  
  • What types of customers are being acquired  
  • Whether activity is driving incremental growth  

Ultimately, the risk is rarely the technology itself. It is how success is defined, measured and validated. This is where agencies play a critical role, helping clients establish the right KPIs, measurement frameworks and data signals so that platform optimisation aligns with genuine business outcomes rather than simply improving platform metrics.  

The platforms run the campaigns and also report on their performance. How do you check that the results are real and incremental?  

This is where having a robust measurement framework becomes critical.  

While platform reporting provides valuable insight, we look beyond it using econometric modelling, multi-touch attribution and incrementality testing to understand the true business impact. The platforms themselves increasingly support this approach through experimentation tools and conversion lift studies.  

A structured test-and-learn programme is also essential. The objective is to test one variable at a time and clearly understand the outcome being measured.  

One important consideration is understanding how automated solutions interact with existing activity. For example, if Performance Max reports strong results, we need to understand whether it has genuinely driven new demand or simply captured conversions that would otherwise have come through Brand or Search activity.  

This is where experiments, holdout groups and lift studies become particularly valuable. They help determine whether investment is creating incremental value or simply changing attribution.  

At Omnicom Media, we are also working with platform partners to help shape how these solutions evolve against client objectives. For some retailers that means unlocking greater omni-channel incrementality. For others, particularly bricks-and-mortar brands, it means connecting media investment more directly to store visits and offline outcomes.  

The real goal is not to understand which campaign received the conversion credit. It is to understand the additional business outcome created by the investment.  

 

A black and white photo of a group of people standing in front of a wall, with their shadows cast on the surface of the wall.

If the platform handles bidding, targeting and placement, where does your team add the most value? What does that look like day to day?  

There is sometimes a perception that as platforms automate, the role of the biddable practitioner becomes obsolete. In reality, the role of a biddable buyer has evolved significantly.  

Today’s practitioners spend less time manually adjusting bids and audiences and more time ensuring platforms have the right signals, objectives and guardrails to optimise effectively. The value increasingly sits across: 

  • Data strategy  
  • Measurement and effectiveness  
  • Creative optimisation  
  • Governance and compliance  
  • Platform and AI expertise  

A growing part of the role is understanding why performance is changing rather than simply reacting to it. That could mean improving conversion tracking, strengthening data quality, identifying platform shifts or ensuring optimisation remains aligned to business objectives.  

Creative is also becoming a much bigger part of media optimisation. With Performance Max and AI Max, we now have greater visibility into how individual assets and combinations of assets contribute to performance. Asset-level reporting, performance labels and combination insights help us understand which messages, formats and creative themes are resonating most effectively.  

At Omnicom Media, this creates a continuous feedback loop between media and creative teams, where performance insights shape creative strategy and each iteration provides stronger inputs back into the algorithm.  

In other words, the role has shifted from optimising campaigns to optimising the environment in which AI operates, combining data, technology, measurement and human judgement to drive growth.

More broadly, agencies play a critical role in connecting platform optimisation to wider business goals, ensuring data strategy, measurement frameworks, creative development and commercial objectives are working together rather than operating in silos. 

Which inputs make the biggest difference to performance, whether that’s data, conversion tracking, product feeds or creative? And which tend to get overlooked?  

All of these inputs play an important role, but the two most overlooked are data quality and conversion tracking.  

The richer and more accurate the signals being fed into platforms, the better the algorithms can optimise. Likewise, robust conversion tracking ensures platforms are learning from outcomes that genuinely matter to the business. At PHD UK (?)we have worked with clients to incorporate online and offline conversion data and have seen incrementality improvements of up to 90% in conversion lift scores.  

The quality of the conversion signal is particularly important. More conversion data is not necessarily better if the platform is learning from actions that do not represent genuine business value.  

For example:  

  • Lead generation brands should optimise towards qualified leads rather than form fills.  
  • Retailers should consider revenue, margin and customer value rather than transaction volume alone.  

Product feeds and creative are equally important. Product feeds provide information on pricing, availability and product attributes, while creative gives platforms the variety needed to test, learn and optimise effectively.  

The reality is that many organisations are still on a maturity journey when it comes to MarTech, first-party data and measurement. Often the challenge is not the technology itself, but bringing together the people, processes and data required to make these tools work effectively.  

Put simply, Performance Max and Advantage+ are only as strong as the signals, creative assets and measurement frameworks behind them.  

Which kinds of advertiser can get by largely on their own, and where does specialist expertise make the biggest difference?  

The question is less about access to the technology and more about how effectively it is deployed.  

An advertiser with a simple product offering, a clear conversion point and straightforward measurement requirements may be able to manage much of this internally. The challenge becomes significantly greater when dealing with large product ranges, online and offline sales, multiple objectives or complex customer journeys.  

Specialist agency expertise makes the biggest difference in helping brands maximise the value of these platforms. Through our scale and platform relationships, we often gain early access to beta products and emerging capabilities, allowing us to test and understand them before wider release.  

We also bring expertise that extends beyond biddable media, including:  

  • Data strategy  
  • Privacy and governance  
  • Measurement and effectiveness  
  • MarTech integration  
  • Creative optimisation  

In addition, we have developed bespoke audit frameworks that assess everything from tracking and data quality through to campaign structure, creative inputs and measurement. These help identify gaps, benchmark against best practice and uncover growth opportunities.  

Perhaps most importantly, agencies benefit from seeing how products such as Performance Max, AI Max and Advantage+ perform across multiple advertisers, categories and objectives. That breadth of experience enables us to identify shifts in platform behaviour, accelerate learning and help shape future product development with platform partners.  

As automation takes on more of the execution, the greatest value increasingly comes from ensuring platforms are solving the right business problems and being measured against the outcomes that matter most.  

With Google bringing ads into AI Mode and ChatGPT now selling ads, does the PMax and Advantage+ model look like the future of AI ad buying more broadly? What should agency teams be learning now?  

Google’s AI Mode is only just starting to roll out in the UK over this quarter, and advertising within ChatGPT remains relatively new. However, the direction of travel is clear. Performance Max, Advantage+, and AI Max have already shown us what happens when platforms take on more responsibility for targeting, bidding, creative assembly and optimisation.  

Advertisers that invest now in the right infrastructure, data foundations and measurement capabilities will be best positioned to capitalise when these opportunities scale. AI Max is likely to become an important gateway into that future, with advertisers that are already providing high-quality signals and objectives to the platforms gaining a head start.  

The bigger shift is that we increasingly need to think about Search more holistically rather than viewing paid and organic search as separate disciplines. Discovery is becoming more fragmented, with traditional search engines now sitting alongside AI-powered experiences and conversational platforms such as ChatGPT. Context is becoming just as important as intent.  

This is particularly interesting in emerging AI advertising environments, where matching against conversational context may become more important than traditional keyword targeting alone. Understanding the prompts, questions and contexts in which consumers engage with brands will become a key competitive advantage.  

As a result, agency teams need to broaden their focus beyond channel optimisation. Success increasingly relies on bringing together media, data, technology, creative and effectiveness expertise to ensure platforms have the right inputs to drive meaningful business outcomes.  

Ultimately, while AI is changing how campaigns are executed, the fundamentals remain the same: clear objectives, high-quality data, strong measurement and a deep understanding of consumer behaviour. Those foundations will matter even more in an increasingly automated future.  

An animated hand reaching out from behind a string of wires against a blue background. The hand is animated, with the strings of the wires reaching out in all directions.

Published by the IPA, the IPA AI Magazine helps member agencies make sense of the fast-changing AI landscape, with practical insights, expert perspectives and real-world applications of generative AI.
Managing Editor: Conor Nichols
Design: Jenna Betts

© 2026 The Institute of Practitioners in Advertising. All rights reserved. No part of this site may be reproduced without our permission.

This is a Shorthand story for reviewPublished stories don't show this section.

GIVE FEEDBACK TO THE STORY OWNER

This feature is not available in landscape. Please rotate your device.

GIVE FEEDBACK TO THE STORY OWNER

More than 4 characters is required
Name must contain only letters, hyphens, apostrophes, full-stops and spaces
Wait, that does not look like a valid email address!
Your feedback was sent to the story owner.
There is been an issue with submitting your feedback.

TEST ON ANOTHER DEVICE

This feature is not available in landscape. Please rotate your device.

TEST ON ANOTHER DEVICE